10 Best New Jersey Crime Podcasts

1. New Jersey Horror Collective

This is your one stop shop for every podcast in the New Jersey Horror Collective! From Horror Wars, to Merky Monday Music Reviews and everything in between. We have reviews, interviews, general chat, true crime, and so much more! Please take the time to check us out!
podcasters.spotify.com
Facebook Followers 2.1KTwitter Followers 102Instagram Followers 14.2K Frequency 1 episode / month Avg Length 66 min Play Get Email Contact

2. Father Wants Us Dead

In 1971, a mild-mannered accountant and Sunday school teacher from New Jersey named John List murders his wife, mother and three children only to disappear and begin a new life entirely on the other side of the country. Now, two veteran journalists go inside the mind of the killer, learn about the doomed family, and revisit the 18-year-quest to bring List to justice a saga even more bizarre and twisted than ever previously reported.
fatherwantsusdead.com
Facebook Followers 1.2MTwitter Followers 594.5KInstagram Followers 509.4K Frequency 1 episode / quarter Avg Length 36 min Play Get Email Contact

3. The Book of the Dead

A weekly true crime podcast, hosted by a mother and daughter, striving to be the voices of those who can no longer speak for themselves. The inspiration behind the Book of the Dead is to shed light on cases and victims that have gone, more or less unnoticed by the media and in other podcasts, instead of focusing on more famous or sensationalized cases, the Book of the Dead does what it can to put focus on the the ones that are more obscure. Join Courtney and Lisa every Sunday for a new case and join them on a journey to get justice for those that have been waiting far too long for it.
botdpod.com
Twitter Followers 125Instagram Followers 2.2K Frequency 3 episodes / month Avg Length 47 min Play Get Email Contact

4. Grim Tales from the Garden State

The New Jersey true crime podcast that dives into the murders, scams, and scandals all in the confines of the Garden StateNew episodes every other Friday!
rss.com
Instagram Followers 192 Frequency 1 episode / quarter Avg Length 21 min Play Get Email Contact

5. NJ Criminal Podcast

Welcome to New Jersey's soapbox and megaphone for legal/lawyer/law-firm podcasting. Join us for NJ law discussions, series, and history. The best place to listen/watch is NJCriminalPodcast.com, where episodes are available by topic, guest, or chronologically.
njcriminalpodcast.com
Facebook Followers 506Twitter Followers 21 Frequency 9 episodes / year Avg Length 44 min Since Mar 2020 Play Get Email Contact

6. Deeply Unsettling

Two girls from New Jersey talk about true crime cases, paranormal and urban legends.
deeplyunsettling.buzzsprout.com
Frequency 18 episodes / year Avg Length 28 min Play Get Email Contact

7. Garden State Cold Case

Did Ted Bundy kill at the Jersey Shore? Who killed a respected NJ teacher's wife and infant son? Why did an NJ mom never return home after going to get ice cream for her kids? Journalist Brian Johnston tells the stories of New Jersey's unsolved murders in Garden State Cold Case.
omny.fm
Frequency 3 episodes / year Avg Length 5 min Play Get Email Contact